What’s the most underrated movie you’ve ever watched?

View all responses

Sometimes, a movie becomes underrated because certain aspects of it aren’t good enough. At other times, perhaps the audience isn’t ready for the kind of story it tries to tell. And sometimes, a movie has so much potential that it’s disappointing to see it go unexplored.

One example that comes to my mind is The Sorcerer’s Apprentice. It’s a modern fantasy adventure involving ancient magic, powerful sorcerers, and a reluctant apprentice. I found it entertaining and imaginative, but I feel its potential for a much richer magical universe was never fully explored. It could have given us so many more stories!

Then there’s the Fantastic Beasts series. I enjoyed its magical world, which took us beyond Hogwarts and introduced us to fascinating magical creatures. It also explored the complicated relationship between Albus Dumbledore and Gellert Grindelwald.

What disappoints me most is that we never got to see the story reach its intended conclusion. I wanted to witness the legendary confrontation between Dumbledore and Grindelwald, a battle that had been anticipated for so long. The series was originally planned as five movies, but only three were released. The franchise was subsequently put on hold, leaving the larger story unfinished on screen.

I understand that movies depend on commercial success, audience reception, and many other factors. Still, as someone who enjoys fantasy, I can’t help wondering what those final two movies might have offered us.

Sometimes, though, a movie doesn’t simply need a sequel. It needs to be remade.

Take Eragon, for example. I love the idea behind the story: a young farm boy discovers a dragon egg, becomes a Dragon Rider, and finds himself caught up in a struggle against a tyrannical ruler. Christopher Paolini’s books offer a much larger world filled with dragons, magic, ancient languages, and political conflicts. I even own the books in the series!

Unfortunately, the 2006 movie adaptation didn’t do justice to the richness of the source material. So much of what makes the books special couldn’t be fully explored in a single film. The planned movie sequels never materialized, leaving readers without a continuation of the story on screen.

I’d love to see a faithful adaptation that gives the books the time, attention, and care they deserve.

Perhaps that’s what makes these movies special to me. They remind me that a fascinating fictional universe can contain far more stories than a film or two can tell.

Sometimes, what makes a movie disappointing isn’t necessarily what we get to see. It’s everything we imagine could have been there.

And perhaps that’s the real tragedy of an unfinished fantasy series: the world doesn’t stop existing in our imagination just because the movies stop being made.